Should You Update WinXP To Service Pack 3?

April 27, 2008

With Service Pack 3 for Windows XP set to be released to the public in less than 48 hours on the 29th of April, I’m mulling over a whole lot of decisions.

You would think a new Service Pack would be a good thing on the face of it, right? Generally speaking, that should be the case. It should make your system safer if nothing else.

However, there are some issues to watch out for if you decide to update to Service Pack 3. One that irritates me (and shows how ridiculous things happen with all sorts of software for all sorts of reasons) is the missing address bar for your taskbar. The Department of Justice required MS to remove the ability to put an address bar on the taskbar, which allows you to launch browser windows (and some apps) without launching a browser first.

DOJ seems to think Internet Explorer is still too tightly integrated with the OS. However, as others have pointed out, it is ridiculous—as using it will launch whatever your default browser is, be it Firefox, Opera or any other. I may not upgrade Windows on my box to SP3 over this issue.

Just kidding. Well, actually, I’m not—but there is a better reason not to.

You won’t be able to uninstall Internet Explorer 7 or Internet Explorer 8 Beta 1 after installing SP3.

Read that again.

If you—like many other XP users (many of my clients resemble this)—are still using Internet Explorer 6 because you’ve had unexplainable crashes and bizarre problems visiting certain websites, updating to SP3 will only enrage you—so I suggest don’t do it, or download Firefox or Opera. Besides, the Department of Homeland Security recommended businesses should stop using Internet Explorer quite some time ago due to the security issues with it.

But wait, just like one of those crappy late night commercials, there’s more!

SP3 installs a new .dll file called Wlanapi.dll, and which some wireless networking devices use. That means if you’re using wireless networking, you want to check beforehand for that .dll on your XP system. If it is there, SP3 will overwrite it for you conveniently so that your third party networking device produces errors of the worst kind. Translated, your “network fall down, go boom.”

So, over the course of the next two days, I am going to be reviewing the SP3 particulars and trying to decide what I’m going to suggest to my biggest client with regards to their multiple networks. Which is why I have been up all night and am awake at 5 AM in the morning on a Sunday. Just what I needed, another MS generated headache.

As if I haven’t had enough already.

Still, I shouldn’t complain. Windows systems were just getting smoothed out and operators were settling in and the bugs and quirks all figured out…work was slowing down. Should I be angry that work will probably pick up some thanks to another problematic MS product release?

One of these days, I’m going to be able to say, “Sorry, I don’t work on Windows systems anymore.” If all goes well, it will be within the next year. What a joyous day it will be, too…

Entry Filed under: Beliefs, Business, Computers, Employment, Everything Else, Internet, Life, News, Opinion, Personal, Random, Random Thoughts, Reading, Security, Software, Technology, Thoughts. .

2 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Carrie  |  April 27, 2008 at 2:03 pm

    Hi Sean,

    I am so glad you gave the heads up on this service pack. Normally, I’d just go right on ahead and download what my HP Updater gives me. I think you’ve recommended before to consider switching from Explorer to Firefox, for example. I need to investigate which version of IE I’m currently running, because that would be downright silly to have a program installed that I can’t uninstall that. Who was the wizard that came up with that plan? Big dummies. Oh well, I’m still pretty tickled with XP, so I shan’t gripe too much. Just glad that there are some workarounds available.

    Speaking of workarounds, you sure do work around the clock sometimes. 5 AM? That’s a fine example of a brain on coffee and all things Windows. You should have your weekends free for other more enjoyable things, and I’m glad you are making steps to say, “Sorry, I don’t work on Windows systems anymore.” Although, I’m sure your clients will miss your dedication.

    Somehow, though, I think you’ll find something else to fill up your time. Hopefully, it’ll be something that won’t cause you headaches, and if you wish to stay up until 5 AM, it’ll be doing something you are excited about.

    Take care, and thanks again for the valuable Service Pack information!

  • 2. Sean Wilson  |  April 27, 2008 at 3:09 pm

    Carrie,

    Thanks for dropping by to read and offer your thoughts on the matter. I’m going to research SP3 more over the next few days and post additional details here on the blog.

    I suppose I will end up using my own system as a guinea pig though I am loathe to do so.

    Yes, I have the remarkable ability to worry at all hours of the day, lol. I thought I was going to head to bed at a decent hour last night, and caught mention of the pending release. When I discovered that Tuesday morning is likely to be chaotic, I decided it would be worth the lost sleep ahead of time to have a handle on it and like a good Boy Scout, “Be prepared.”

    Again, thanks for dropping by. Have a wonderful day! :)

Leave a Comment

Required

Required, hidden

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Impetus

Caffeine fueled emarketing, politics, business, Linux, philosophy, beer, boxing, music, technology, and writing. And other stuff, too...




Ron Paul 2008 - Hope for America

Site Map & Suggestions

Top Posts

Archives

Pages

Feeds

We're Discussing

Community

2k Bloggers


Contact me about reciprocal linking and getting your site listed in my blogroll.

Links

Spam Blocked

Blog Stats

Showing Support